Best Pilots Scene: Round 3

[rayruz.livejournal.com]

Thanks everyone for voting, yesterday, I think today might be a little bit harder because we're getting down to the best of the best. I'll get an extra discussion post up later, but feel free to debate like crazy. Here are your next 4 matchups. (If you haven't figured out the pattern, this round is the best one for each season.)[Poll #1570475]

Also, just so you guys know, I'm being whisked around at strange hours tomorrow, yipes. So today's DPP is going to be a sorta two day thing... and the Round 4 poll will probably be posted around 10 or 11 EST tonight.

Comments

[damao2010.livejournal.com]

For me too, season two was the most difficult to decide on. I was kind of leaning towards the "Are we OK?" scene because it reflects the development of their relationship and how, despite their misgivings, they can't help but reach out and forgive each other, whereas in the "No takebacks" shot, their conversation is lighter and less angst-ridden (I really love their playfulness and teasing) but, they still held back. Your reasoning, linking both scenes by stating that "THIS IS THE SCENE WHERE THEY DON'T TAKE IT BACK" helped me dispell any doubts I might have had. So, now, I have to vote for "Are we OK?".

[rachelindeed.livejournal.com]

Yay! I have unreasonable love for both scenes, but I think "The Captain's Hand" runs deeper. And since it will be facing off with the Brig scene soon, I think this may be our last chance to express our appreciation for it :)