no_takebacks | DPP: It's Supernatural! (Reply)

Hey kids, I'm driving the DPP train this week, so get ready cause here it comes!

Thought we'd kick off this week by starting with some wild and wacky. BSG was often praised for being a realistic, down-to-earth show despite the "evil robots in space" basic premise. But for today, let's embrace the over-the-top, out-of-this-world possibilities. Here's a list of imaginary or supernatural creatures and ideas. How would you incorporate one or more events into the show? How would Kara or Lee react if they were to come in contact with some of these things? Who would be the Scully (skeptic) and who would be the Mulder (true believer)? Write a fic if you feel moved, a drabble or something longer, or just give us the title or the first line. Sky's the limit.

vampires
unicorns
elves
werewolves
zombies
ghosts
dragons
time travel
psychic abilities (telepathy, telekinesis, etc)
soul bonding
magic spells
aliens (not counting cylons)
any other paranormal element you can come up with

Here's some visual inspiration to get you going!